
I first heard Dan Le Sac Vs Scroobius Pip years ago on Radio One. There was a feature Colin Murray used to do back when he was in control of the evening show where he would, basically, throw an hour a week open to whatever his listeners had sent in that would never normally get air time. Somebody sent in Thou Shalt Always Kill. I thought it was brilliant. But, not paying attention, I missed both the song title, and the artist name. Never mind, eh?
Fast forward maybe 18 months, and a friend whose music taste I have always rated was listening to the duo’s first album. Listening to it a lot. He never recommended it to me, as such, but I was, frankly curious. This curiosity got me listening. That album was Angles. It was sharp, clever, relevant, and made me question my previously unassailable hatred of Hip-Hop. At the time, I was a metal kid. This was a big deal.
When the bands second album, Logic of Chance, was released in 2010, I was too nervous to listen to it for the longest time. Angles was held up high on a pedestal in my head, and I was terrified that the new album wouldn’t meet my expectations. I was, sadly, correct in doing so. Logic of Chance seemed to have lost everything that made their debut special. It wasn’t as sharp, it wasn’t as clever. There were no long narrative lyrics. Instead, Pip’s lyrics seemed preachy, almost forced.
Repent, Replenish, Repeat is the third album by Dan Le Sac Vs. Scroobius Pip. Since their last release, both members have released independent solo work, and they seem closer for it. Whilst Logic of Chance seemed fragmented, almost forced, in RRR the duo finally seem back on the same page – although not quite to the extent of Angles, which is still very secure in being their best work.
Le Sac’s input in particular has improved so as to almost be unrecognisable from his earlier work on Angles, and it serves to make me really want to get around to listening to his solo stuff. Here he is definite, solid, and accomplished. On some of the weaker lyrical tracks (Heroism, Entity) it’s enough to make you stick around.
The strongest tracks lyrically, however, are simultaneously the weakest musically. This illustrates what I believe is the biggest factor holding the pair back. In a recent ‘tweet along’ for the album, I asked Pip clarification on how the songs are written. It appears that it changes: sometimes a beat is delivered to Pip for him to write over, and sometimes lyrics are given to Le Sac and he works from those. The two don’t seem to write together. As such, there is rarely true unity between the two components.
Despite this disparity, there really are some great tracks on the album. Terminal is a return to the narrative tracks from Angles, a short, sad story about a drug fuelled night. Porter is another brilliant throwback, the only real track in which both components seem to match perfectly, and an interesting experiment on what seems to be a central idea: what if all the Disney princesses were just insane? You Will See Me is also a brilliant, if angry, introspective lyric.
Sadly, there are also tracks that almost beg to be skipped. Stiff Upper Lip is the most obvious of these. It’s loud, angry, and devoid of any real substance. In Angles, societal or political tracks were subtle, humorous, and effective because of it. Here, we just have bile – not helped by Itch, formerly of The King Blues, who contributes a truly unpleasant sound.
Gold Teeth is nowhere near as objectionable, but it suffers from having no real purpose. It seems like a track made solely to be a radio single, and it doesn’t seem like it should be a Dan Le Sac Vs Scroobius Pip track.
Repent, Replenish, Repeat is by no means a bad album, and certainly improves on the duo’s 2010 attempt. However, it still sits in the shadow of the pair’s debut, and while certain tracks strive to regain those heights, others conspire to drag it down further.





